Best Eyeliner For Oily Lids Every Woman Should Own

March 18, 2018

Jelly Bell

Best Eyeliner For Oily Lids Every Woman Should Own

Table of Contents [ Hide ]

Imagine that you proudly share your perfect cat eyes on Snapchat for the whole world to see. But later, your eyelids start to get glossy over, and your liner becomes blurred. This scenario is all the same to us, right?

So if you’re one of those women out there who has been struggling all the time to keep your eyeliner looking neat for several hours, then don’t worry! We’re going to reveal what types of eyeliner you can swear by, keep reading below! Who knows? One of them can be your best eyeliner for oily lids that other women would love to have in their makeup bags!

What’s the best eyeliner for oily lids?

Women tend to find the BEST EYELINER FOR WATERLINE so that they can have ideally defined eyes. It helps them create the illusion of naturally-long lashes, adding sparkle to nearly any look. Today is your lucky day since we’re going to tell you the best eyeliner for oily lids that can stay on the whole day. Check out our roundup below and do all the testing for you [1].

#1 Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner

Among many waterproof liquid eyeliners available on the market, this is seen as the best eyeliner for oily lids. Its smudge-proof formula glides smoothly on your lids, dries fast, and won’t run from day to night. If you’re seeking a true eye-opening effect from the eyeliner product, go to test Stila liquid eyeliner now, it won’t let disappoint you. Just get ready for a dramatic and sexy look with it!  

Finally, a waterproof liquid liner can steal our hearts. It’s easy to use and stay in place until you remove it! What could be better than that? We always look for the best way on HOW TO KEEP EYELINER FROM RUNNING all the time. Now we’ve got it – the finest marker-like eyeliner in hand. It comes in 12 beautiful shades, from black, brown, grey, white, green to blue. All of these have bold pigmentation, making it one of the BEST EYELINER FOR CONTACT LENS WEARERS.

However, it might go on with ease on waterline without skipping or smudging due to your sweat; it’s not as long-lasting as the Urban Decay pencil. It means you probably must touch it up again, especially any blurred spot after hours. Besides, according to some users, the liquid liner performs quite well in all corners of the eyes.

Even when you draw a cat eye flick in that corner, your fine line still stays there all day! There’s nothing to worry about sweat that might impact it either. After all, we rank it high here because it’s just the best eyeliner for oily lids you’ve been searching for.


  • High pigmentation and precise-felt tip
  • Best recommended for beginners
  • Long-lasting and shine-free
  • Easy to use


  • A bit like a drying-up marker
  • Uneven color

Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner

Check Current Price

#2 Maybelline Makeup Eyestudio Lasting Drama Gel Eye Liner

Why will you love it? It’s not only the best eyeliner for oily lids but also the most intense one for adding drama to your whole look. With a unique oil-free formula, the gel eyeliner finds no difficulty in holding highly-concentrated pigments in its clear gel texture. Like the first one, this is known for creating the smudge-proof, and waterproof eye looks within 24 hours.

Let’s use it to make up your most dramatic look than ever! Are you obsessed with the little strokes? No problem! Just glide the eyeliner across your lash line from the innermost to the outermost corner of the eye. The gel has a brilliant power to extend and thicken every line from all corners towards your brows. For a bit drama, try to wing the line out.

My female friends always ask me “WHAT IS THE BEST EYELINER FOR WATERY EYES?” And I’m easily mixed up with such a question. Now I’ve got the answer – it’s Maybelline Makeup Eyestudio Lasting Drama Gel Eye Liner. Unlike other liquid liners, which easily cracks and become faded, this one isn’t like that at all! It’s not just smooth on your waterline but also able to stay locked the whole day.

Better than this, if your eye skin is sensitive, this product is still suitable for you since it doesn’t contain any chemical-like scent. So if there’s any best eyeliner for oily lids and sensitive eye skin, I recommend Maybelline gel eye liner to those of all skin tones and ages.


  • Stays locked all day
  • Extremely smooth on the waterline
  • Not irritating sensitive skin
  • None of the chemical-like scent


  • Not easy to apply
  • Gel base is not suitable for some users

Maybelline Makeup Eyestudio Lasting Drama Gel Eye Liner

Check Current Price

#3 NYKKOLA Makeup Waterproof Leopard Shell Liquid Eyeliner Pen

Another best eyeliner for oily lids we’d like to put on the list is NYKKOLA makeup waterproof eyeliner pen. It’s exclusively made with a decent-quality synthetic bristles so that you find it easier to use or handle it. Not to mention when you have the habits of walking around with your makeup bag, this is also easy to carry around.  

If you love dramatic eyeliner, then don’t miss this chance but buy it at once. But HOW LONG DOES LIQUID EYELINER LAST? Since the product is made by hand by the professional artists so that they would guarantee that it has longevity in use. It can turn into a sticker all day until you decide to peel your eye wing off. And when removing it, this won’t smudge or smear anywhere. This characteristic just tells us that it’s the best eyeliner for oily lids.

Once applying it, you’ll notice a difference as compared to other eyeliners – it goes smoothly even on your waterline. The tool has an amazing performance with its firm tip, allowing you to control and use it easier. Besides, it has a pretty sharp black that can dry down fast, which later leaves on your eyelids the prettiest matte than ever!  

Go to test it, and then you’ll see that it didn’t crack even a bit. Don’t ever think that cheap stuff would never work! Even when you have the sensitive skin, it won’t irritate or damage it at all.


  • Dry down fast
  • Owns a sharp black
  • Goes smoothly on the waterline
  • Not irritating sensitive skin


  • Gets flaky at times
  • A bit more watery

NYKKOLA Makeup Waterproof Leopard Shell Liquid Eye Liner

Check Current Price

#4 L’Oréal Paris Infallible Super Slim Liquid Eyeliner, Black

Are you in search of the best eyeliner for oily lids? Then create the perfectly clean lines with this Super Slim liquid eyeliner right now. Its long-wear finest-felt tip could help you draw the most precise lines without smudging yet with constant flow. Only in one single stroke, you can create the sleek and delicate eye looks that will last more than 12 hours. Make sure to apply it at the top and the bottom lash line in the corner of your eyes.

The application is pretty easy, too. This is ideal for those who want to have a more defined look, with a thinner and slimmer cat eye. Let’s begin from the innermost corner of your eyes and then work towards the middle. The tip feels a bit harder and firmer, so no matter how many times you try to pull and drag the eyeliner across the waterline, it goes smoothly.  

Trust me or not, L’Oreal eyeliner will leave a flawless finish and crazily long-lasting line. There’s nothing to complain about it. Smooth, waterproof, and pigmented are the noticeable adjectives to describe the eyeliner.

More importantly, it’s dark yet not as harsh as some others. You might like the way it’s designed and easy to handle. During the application, things are getting easier except the fact that it’s a bit dry.


  • Smooth and waterproof
  • High consistency
  • Gives perfect lines
  • Easy to use and handle


  • The pigment is not as bold as expected
  • Drier than liquid liner

L'Oréal Paris Infallible Super Slim Liquid Eyeliner

Check Current Price

#5 Docolor Liquid Eyeliner Eye Liner Gel Black

It’s time to create the sharpest design of your own, with Docolor Liquid Eyeliner Eye Liner Gel Black! The product can create different makeup styles with its thick or thin lines based on your preference. Better than this, you’re not confused anymore on how to keep your eyeliner from traveling away down your face. Docolor eyeliner is exactly the best eyeliner for oily lids when it can stick to your eye skin without budging all day.

Even when you have the hooded lids that are extremely oily, making it nearly impossible to find an eyeliner that suits you. Now with this magical eyeliner, you can get splashed or dip yourself in the water without worrying if it budges or not. The formula is just great as compared to the other high-end name brands.

It doesn’t smudge on the base or top, or won’t cake in any corner of your beautiful eyes after the application. The product just goes smoothly with an ideal finish. Besides, another bonus from this eyeliner is that it doesn’t have long-lasting power but can be removed easily with your makeup removers.

For all of these reasons, we love to name it as the best eyeliner for oily lids. Think about the moment when you sleep with makeup on, and then it goes smudged and horrible in the next morning. But not with this product! It’s a little bit blurred if you look at it closely.


  • Extremely smooth and sharp eyeliner
  • Safe to use
  • Long-lasting
  • Bold pigmentation


  • A bit flakey
  • Hard to apply

Docolor Liquid Eyeliner Eye Liner Gel Black

Check Current Price

How to keep your eyeliner last when you sweat?

Some of these tips and tricks on HOW TO KEEP EYELINER FROM SMUDGING UNDER EYES we’re going to share now can be applied to the reality. Therefore, do not rush to hide your favorite summer goodies away soon. It’s still possible to get the best of your summer collection no matter how sweaty you might be. Your overall makeup or particular eyeliner can get better since it can last through anything, like a meltdown for instance.

Remove eye makeup and use eyeshadow primer

One of the most important things to bear in mind is that you must always keep your skin as fresh as possible. Let’s start removing makeup from your eyelids with an oil-free remover. You can choose Neutrogena for the best result. It’s perfect for drawing the excess oils that might create the crease on your lids.

Next, before choosing the best eyeliner for oily lids, make sure to give them the lasting power. When it comes to this, apply your reliable eyeshadow primer to the lids. Later, you can set your primer with eyeshadow, and it’s fine to combine it with your translucent powder. This duo could do more amazing things to increase the longevity of your eye makeup [2].  

Use your eyeshadow

If you usually use gel eyeliner, then it’s best to know about this trick for sure. To give your gel-like eyeliners greater staying power, you have to top off the liner with a suitable eyeshadow. Not just this offer your liner an attractive smoky effect, but it also sets the liner for the rest of your day.

When applying it on top of the eyes to seal it, you need to dab every corner of the eyelid, too.Ensure to avail the shade that matches well with the color of your best eyeliner for oily lids.

Reach for the clear sealant

Another great trick that all famous makeup artists would do most of the time. For anyone who has the oily eyelids or watery eyes, let’s consider topping your eyeliner with a high-quality sealant. More importantly, this liquid is believed to build up a barrier circling the liner so that you can lock it in place for hours. This also helps make your eyeliner resistant to water.  

Start curling and apply liner

We suggest curling your eyelashes before applying your best eyeliner for oily lids. But right after you apply the liner, let’s stop curling them since it will easily take the eyeliner off your eyes. Also, doing this way could ensure that less smudging after the application.

Remember that before applying the eyeliner, you should match it to your skin type just like how you do with the foundation. It’s because the skin is the reason that can make your makeup or the eyeliner runs off. For any woman who has the more oily skin, you probably want to avoid from using the soft-formulated liners and even gel liners. These easily smudge whenever your skin isn’t dry.

Also, one of the best tricks that every makeup artists would use for a full yet natural-looking eyelashes is availing the BEST EYELINER FOR TIGHTLINING. So go ahead and try it out if you find it helpful for your natural makeup.

Seal it with a setting spray

After the eye makeup application, ensure to seal it by spritzing the skin with your setting spray. This spray might serve as a barrier that can help lock your eyeliner quite effectively. Moreover, doing so can help boost the overall longevity of the liner.

Layer the eyeliners

Another essential trick to increase the wear-time of your eyeliner is layering the liners. According to the professional makeup artists, doing this can truly enhance their longevity. For example, you tend to use the pencil liner, then try to layer a liquid gel liner on the top of the eyelids to seal in its color.  

Let’s give these handy tricks a try since they will help your long-lasting makeup without a doubt. The eyeliner never smudges if you won’t let it do.  


Having the eyeliner is a big requirement for any particular makeup routine. Well, no woman could ever leave home without putting on eyeliner or putting it in her makeup bag. But the problem takes place when you have the oily lids. So hopefully with some of our eyeliner tips today, you’re going to learn what the best eyeliner for oily lids is and how to let it stay on your face without melting it away so fast.

When it comes to this list, trust it since it’s a good fix for this issue. They will grab on tight to your eyelids and hold on for hours. Therefore, choose your favorite out of them so that your makeup can stay on the greasy skin during the day.

Related Post